Archive for art

Stock Icon Libraries :: Why They Suck

So I finally launched the latest and greatest version of FloSpace FloPrompter 2.0 a couple of weeks ago. What a journey it was… It’s tough enough trying to figure out how to bend Microsoft components to one’s will. It’s also much harder than it should be to find a thoughtfully complete stock icon library.

I placed special emphasis on “thoughtfully complete” because there are a lot of stock icon libraries out there, and most are complete crap. Or they’re woefully incomplete. Or seem to have been made by graphically inclined monkeys because they’re full of random unrelated icons that would never appear in the same application together.

For little companies like mine which have an extremely limited budget, a stock icon library is the only real choice one has. For $100 - $300, you get a bunch of professionally-made images that you can use in your software product or web site with no additional royalty payments. It’s an inexpensive way to add a touch of polish to your project.

Or, rather, it should be. Except most stock icon libraries suck.

First, let me tell you about the stock icon library that I used and why this one is a fantastic deal at just $199. Glyph Lab is the name of the company and the graphic designer who runs the show, Dave W., was a pleasure to work with. I had a couple of questions and Dave was extremely responsive to them. I wrote to Dave and said that I thought his icon library was missing a couple of icons that are core to a text editor set, and he not only agreed with me, but he also gave them to me for free rather than charging me extra. (And they ought to have been added to the complete commercial set now, I believe.)

Let me also sing the praises of why I think the Glyph Lab set is the best set out there and why it deserves the moniker of the most “thoughtfully complete” set around. (And I’ve looked at dozens of sets!)

Icons come in logical sets, depending on the features of the product. It’s clear that Glyph Lab is the only company which thought through the needs of application developers when deciding what kinds of icons to create.

  • Standard Application Icons: Almost all desktop applications are going to need the following sets of icons: New Document, Open, Save, Save As, Print, Print Setup, Print Preview, Options, and Close.
  • Secondary: Some applications like FloPrompter also have import and export features, so these two basic icons should be included.
  • Edit Icons: Almost all applications have basic editing features: Cut, Copy, Paste, Undo, Redo, and Select All.
  • Wordprocessing Icons: Any application which provides “rich” text editing features needs a complete set of icons. What drives me crazy is that of all the icon libraries I looked at, only Glyph Lab had icons for all of these features: Bold, Italic, Underline, Strikeout, Text Color, Bullets, Indent, Unindent, Left Align, Center Align, Right Align.
  • Media Playback: Although FloPrompter doesn’t play music or video, I use the media playback metaphor for controlling the scrolling and also navigating through the various “broadcast segments” (text snippets) that the author has written. Icons in this set must include: Play, Pause, Stop, Next, Previous, First, Last.

I’ve actually developed a full list of categories and lists of icons that should be included in each category. I grew so frustrated at one point that I spent a week or two researching all of that! There for awhile, I considered starting my own icon design company simply to create thoughtfully packaged and complete icon sets for application developers based on the type of features in their product. Other categories based around feature sets include:

  • 2D Drawing: This is a large set of icons including basic 2D geometric shapes, object alignment, space distribution, grouping, and related features.
  • 3D Drawing: Some special purpose icons, including light effects, 3D shapes, 3D navigation, etc.
  • Chat: Only a dozen or so icons related to buddy list management and presence (e.g., available, offline, invisible, etc.). Skype has the most robust sets of features and presence statuses I’ve seen, so you’d want to plan for at least that many. All of the other systems, like AOL, MSN, Yahoo, etc., appear to basically have different sub-sets of the total Skype set of presence statuses.
  • Database Record Management & Navigation: I probably should have put this one first because so many custom-built desktop software is based on using custom databases. The one thing that drives me crazy is that graphic designers often forget the lifecycle factor: For every object that is created, you must account for its editing and deletion, as well. Those are the three universal steps in an object’s lifecycle. Many objects have additional stages, especially once workflow processes are taken into account.

So one of the major points of this rant is a request to stock icon library makers: Don’t keep slapping random icons together like you’re doing now! Think about which of these feature sets you’re going to support, and them create a complete set of icons for that feature set (such as all of the icons I’d need for a basic wordprocessing program, or database mgmt. application). I’m coming to you as a solution provider. Provide me with a total solution – don’t do a half-ass job of it, as my mother would say. After all, I want my software product to look good and for its icons to look like they were all drawn by the same hand in the same style.

Well, I will spare the readership any additional ranting. But if any enterprising graphic designer out there reads this post and sees more clearly what developers ACTUALLY need and changes his or her ways accordingly, I’ll have done my job.

In the meantime, if you’re in the market for an excellent set of stock icons at a great price, Glyph Lab is the set for you. Unfortunately, they’re also the only decent set out there. Check them out:

www.GlyphLab.com

Comments

A View from the Bridge

Who knew that Chelsea had a really good theater company?? I’ve been in Boston for almost 7 years and I swear I’d never heard of them before.

But there they are. The Chelsea Theatre Works has a fantastic building smack in the middle of Chelsea Center. The building used to be the old Odd Fellows hall. They’ve done a great job of remodeling the building and modernizing it, too.

Check out their web site to learn more about the Arthur Miller tragic play, “A View from the Bridge.” All I’ll say is that the acting was better than what you’d expect from a small theater company like this. The guy who played the main character, Eddie, was fantastic. The actor’s name is Jeff Gill and he commanded every scene. Tickets are just $15 in advance or $18 at the door and worth every penny.

Afterwards, my two friends and I went down the street to Cinco de Mayo, a Mexican restaurant with a great reputation. Unfortunately, we just had drinks so I didn’t have a chance to sample their food. But the margarita was good (on the rocks, no salt). And a few minutes after sitting down, most of the cast and crew came in for nibblies and drinks, too. Very cool.

Check out “A View from the Bridge” and enjoy its many parallels to life in immigrant-dominated Chelsea in the shadow of the Tobin Bridge. Fridays and Saturdays at 8:00, Sunday matinees at 3:00 through December 10. See the web site for more information:

http://www.theatrezone.org/

By the way, I couldn’t find a web site, but I found a review for it at Yelp. They’re located at 139 Winnisimmet St. in Chelsea, about a block from the police station. Next time I go to a play there, I’ll definitely have to head to Cinco de Mayo first for dinner to finally see what all the chatter is about.

Comments

A Painting a Day

My friend Jeff Hayes is an aspiring artist. Well, he’s not just “aspiring” — he’s doing! And not only is he just doing — he’s painting a picture every day.

Yes, you read that correctly: every day!

How cool is that?

Visit his web site and see what’s he’s been up to. Click on the “Painting a Day” link to view thumbnails of the paintings for each day.

I should also mention that he has a show coming up in Boston. If you’re in the Boston area, stop by his studio during the next First Friday Open House:

450 Harrison First Friday Opening
450 Harrison Ave, Studio 201, Boston, MA 02118
Friday, December 1, 2006 from 5pm to 9pm

For more information, visit Jeff’s web site: www.jeffhayes.com

Comments